Guide · 7 min read

How to Find Off-Market Properties and Wholesale Deals for Investment

Where off-market and wholesale deals come from, how to reach the owners, and how to judge a deal in minutes.

An off-market property is one that is for sale without a public listing through an agent. The owner may sell directly, through a wholesaler or through an estate. Fewer buyers see it, so an off-market deal can face less competition, but it is not automatically cheaper: you still have to check the numbers yourself.

FindOffMarket brings off-market and wholesale properties across Canada and the US into one place, and emails you the new ones that match your search.

This guide covers where off-market and wholesale deals come from, how to reach the owners, and how to judge a deal in a few minutes before you spend more time on it. The same methods work in Canada and the US. The rules on marketing, contracts and closing differ by province and state, so check them where you buy.

Where off-market deals come from

Most off-market deals start with an owner who wants to sell without the time, cost or exposure of a public listing: an inherited house, a tired landlord, a property that needs more work than most homebuyers will take on, or an owner who has to move quickly. Investors reach those owners in a few ways.

Direct to owner

You contact owners yourself, by letter, phone or at the door, usually working from a list: absentee owners, rentals held for many years, vacant properties, or homes with years of deferred maintenance. It is slow and most answers are no, but the deals you do find have no middleman. Anti-spam, do-not-call and privacy rules apply to this kind of marketing in both countries, so check them before you send anything.

Wholesalers

A wholesaler puts a property under contract with the owner, then sells the right to buy it to an investor for a fee. Good wholesalers bring a steady flow of deals. The catch is that their numbers are a sales pitch, so check every figure yourself. Our guide to wholesale real estate explains how these deals work and how to check one.

Estate and probate sales

When an owner dies, the executor often has to sell, sometimes from far away and often with a house that needs work. Estate lawyers, executors and estate sale companies are useful contacts. These sales take longer, because the estate has to be settled first, and they call for patience and tact.

Expired listings and for-sale-by-owner

A listing that expired without selling, or an owner trying to sell without an agent, points to a seller who may now be open to a direct offer. Approach them politely. An expired listing often means the price was too high for the condition, so your offer has to show how you got to your number.

Driving for dollars

Drive or walk the neighbourhoods you want to buy in and note the houses that look neglected or empty: overgrown yards, boarded windows, mail piling up. Then look up the owner in the public property records and get in touch. It costs little but your time, and it teaches you the area street by street.

Networking

Agents, contractors, property managers, lawyers, mortgage brokers and other investors all hear about properties before they are listed. Local investor meetups are the easiest place to start. Tell people exactly what you buy (the area, the type of property and the price range), and answer quickly when they bring you something that fits, so they bring you the next one too.

A deal service

A service like FindOffMarket brings off-market and wholesale listings into one place, so you can see what is for sale across many areas without keeping a dozen mailing lists and searches going. It doesn't replace the methods above, but it gives you a steady stream of deals to practise on. Browse live off-market properties to see what is for sale near you.

How to judge a deal in minutes

Most deals you see won't work. A quick screen lets you drop those fast and spend your time on the few that might. Before you call anyone, check:

  • Location: would a tenant or a buyer want to live there? Look at the street, schools, transit, and what similar homes nearby rent and sell for. Higher-priced areas often return less, because the price rises faster than the rent. If you buy far from home, a property manager can help.
  • Asking price against the ARV: the after repair value (ARV) is what the property should be worth once it is fixed up. A seller's or wholesaler's ARV is a claim, not a fact, so compare it with recent sales of similar homes nearby.
  • Repairs: price the big items first (roof, foundation, windows, heating, electrical and plumbing) and add a margin for what you can't see. Photos rarely show a property's problems.
  • Rent: what the property would rent for once it is fixed up, judged from current rental listings nearby.
  • Your strategy: a deal that fails as a rental may still work as a flip, and the other way round.

If a deal survives this first pass, visit the property, get a contractor's quote and an inspection, and only then make a firm offer.

The math and the one percent rule

The three most important figures when you evaluate an investment property are the purchase price, the repair cost and the after repair value. For a flip, the rough profit is the ARV minus the repair cost, minus the purchase price, minus the costs of buying, holding and selling. Our guide to wholesale real estate works one flip through to a profit.

For a rental, a common first check is the one percent rule: monthly rent should be at least 1% of the purchase price plus repairs. A $200,000 home needing $20,000 of work should rent for at least $2,200 a month. It ignores expenses, so run the full numbers before you offer.

Here is what the full numbers look like for a rental, as an example: a $250,000 home needing $10,000 of work, rented for $2,300 a month, bought with 20% down and a $200,000 mortgage at 6.5% over 25 years. Your own rate, taxes and insurance will differ.

  • Rent: $2,300 a month
  • Vacancy, at 5% of the rent: −$115
  • Repairs and a reserve for big items, at 10% of the rent: −$230
  • Property tax: −$250
  • Insurance: −$100
  • Mortgage payment: about −$1,350
  • Cash flow: about $255 a month, or $3,060 a year

With about $65,000 of your own money in the deal (the down payment, the repairs and about $5,000 of closing costs), that is a cash-on-cash return of about 4.7% a year, before the mortgage is paid down. Small changes move it a lot: rent 10% lower leaves about $60 a month, a property manager at 8% of the rent leaves about $70, and a rate of 7.5% leaves about $130. This home fails the one percent rule ($2,600) yet still makes a little each month, which is why the rule is a screen, not a verdict.

Want to run these numbers on a real listing? Our free calculators do the math for you.

Investment strategies

Many real estate investment strategies can work, depending on your appetite for risk, your capital and your experience. Some of the most common are:

  • BRRRR: buy, rehab, rent, refinance, repeat
  • Short-term rental, such as an Airbnb or a cottage. Many cities ban or license short-term rentals of homes the owner doesn't live in, so check the local rules before you buy.
  • Long-term rental
  • Fix and flip
  • House hacking: buying a multi-unit property, living in one unit and renting out the others to cover your costs

Once you have a deal, our guide to investment property financing covers how to pay for it.

Where do I find the best investment properties?

You can work with a real estate agent and look at listed properties. Those usually draw many competing offers, and the agents' commission adds to the cost.

You can also join the mailing lists of individual wholesalers, but then the deals are spread across many inboxes and you have to keep checking all of them.

Or use FindOffMarket: we bring off-market and wholesale listings from across Canada and the US into one place, check that they're still up, and tag each one with the investment strategies it fits. Start with:

Smart Money Podcast

Smart Money Podcast

A Canadian podcast about real estate, investing, personal finance and financial education.

Website Podcast Instagram YouTube

Keep reading

More guides

Wholesale Real Estate in Canada and the US

What a wholesale deal is, how an assignment works, and how to check a deal before you sign.

Read the guide

Investment Property Financing: Real Estate Loans for Investors

The loans investors use, what lenders ask for, and how much you need to put down in Canada and the US.

Read the guide

What You Need to Know About Property Insurance for Off-Market and Wholesale Real Estate

What investment property insurance covers, how it differs from homeowners insurance, and how much it costs.

Read the guide

Property Management - Scaling Your Off-market and Wholesale Real Estate Empire

Who needs a property manager, what property management costs, and where to find one.

Read the guide

Find your next off-market deal

New off-market and wholesale listings every day across Canada and the US, each tagged with the strategies it fits. Free to browse, with free email alerts.